Mixed results for Townsville battery trial
Mixed results for Townsville battery trial
By Dean Condon, Technology Innovation Engineer
Ergon Energy’s innovative residential battery trial in Townsville has concluded with some interesting and mixed results.
Small-scale energy storage systems are a game-changer opportunity for customers, networks and retailers in the space of residential energy provision. The solar PV systems wave has well and truly hit. This has enabled small energy users to take energy pricing into their own hands to some degree and to start to change the game.
Residential Battery Energy Storage Systems (resi-BESS) offer customers the ability to store and use later their solar PV generation. There are also a number of Home Energy Management Systems (HEMS) coming on the market that enable customers to view and manage their energy use.
Ergon Energy has for many years been at the leading edge of testing new grid technologies and most recently has been laboratory testing and field trialing resi-BESS.
The trial commenced in the early months of 2015.The field trial is comprised of 10 customers in a single street connected to the same distribution transformer, who have solar PV, BESS and HEMS installed on the customer side of the meter.
Trials were conducted over a 12 month period, and a second phase of new trials is about to commence. In phase 1 three different cost-reflective tariffs were tested throughout the year across these houses where 4 different types of BESS units were installed.
The customer circuits were arranged into three groups in the switchboards:
- Essential: light and power circuits; power is supplied from grid, solar PV or battery storage
- Non-essential: cooking, shed power; power is supplied from grid only
- Controlled: hot water, air conditioning, pool pumps, bore pumps; power is supplied from grid only via economy tariff.
The essential circuits could use power from the grid, solar PV or battery storage and this choice was determined by the BESS which were programmed by Ergon personnel. The BESS control algorithms were proprietary to each vendor, were all very different in setting up and in general all were less sophisticated than desired or expected.
The field trial tested three tariffs with customers in a shadow environment and hence actual costs were not incurred, but a small financial incentive provided motivation to change behaviour based on the tariff details.
The three tariffs tested were: Time of Use (TOU), Capacity (CAP) and Time of Use Demand (TOUD). Each tariff test was conducted for two weeks and analysed against each other and a control period. Customers were given the specific tariff details the week prior to testing and then notified again on the morning the testing commenced.
A significant number of challenges and barriers were encountered during the project. Integrating BESS and HEMS technologies into existing electrical installations was problematic.
Customers experienced a range of issues that included considerable switchboard modifications, lost HEMS data, power outages, undesirable operational outcomes from the BESS and failure of appliances.
The HEMS was a very good energy monitoring device, providing circuit level data in 1 minute intervals. However issues were encountered when attempting to control loads. The lack of integrated communications between the solar PV and the BESS also caused some issues.
There was a large variation in quality and functionality of the BESS units installed on this project and there were issues with all brands of BESS. Increased cost did not correlate with a decrease in issues.
The most expensive unit provided some of the greatest challenges and the least expensive unit was the most reliable but most complex to program.
The total house load was not able to be supplied by the BESS and hence only light and power circuits were powered by the BESS, with grid supply the only source for cooking, pumping and cooling loads.
Results and learnings
Cost-reflective tariffs can provide more accurate price signals to customers for the delivery of energy. Time of Use tariffs are too static and do not always accurately indicate the system or local peak.
Time of Use tariffs also encourage daily cycling of BESS, which reduces life of the batteries when there may not be a need to do so. Capacity and Demand tariffs provide a good signal to customers in regard to household power limits, but without a suitable control system either within the BESS or the HEMS, household load management is almost impossible to achieve.
The Time of Use Demand tariff was complex and customers did not understand it or have an energy management system that could avoid costly impacts. A smarter energy management system ,either as part of the BESS or as a separate HEMS, is needed for demand tariffs.
Customers, energy retailers and networks have different drivers and incentives with regard to operating a BESS. Energy utopia is when these stakeholders all achieve their desired outcomes through a sustainable and cost-effective model (a Win-Win-Win).
Customers with multiple sources of energy (grid and solar PV), storage (BESS) and an advanced energy management system (HEMS) have all of the hardware required to provide the best chance of reducing impact from cost-reflective electricity prices.
This project has shown that without an effective integrated control system, negative grid and customer impacts cannot be avoided. The project has also demonstrated the amount of opportunity for further development of BESS and HEMS to provide improved outcomes for the customer whilst remaining adaptable in the energy market.
The most likely scenario for achieving energy utopia is with a local integrated advanced energy management system that can receive data from local and remote sources, make decisions, and control loads (where desirable), generation and storage to achieve positive outcomes for customers, retailers and networks.
We’re interested in your feedback. If you would like to comment on this article please contact firstname.lastname@example.org
Support for this work has been provided by the Queensland Department of Energy and Water Supply.